Continuing on my brief discussion last post regarding whether or not the Patriots are a dynasty. While I believe the Patriots are a dynasty, I thought it would be interesting to compare the team to previous dynasties in NFL history. I thought one interesting comparison would be the number of pro bowlers on a team, especially considering the Patriots are known for their team play and lack of superstars. So here is what we have:
With the Patriots becoming a dynasty, one can argue that there have been four other dynasties in NFL history, the Packers in the 60's, the Steelers of the 70's, the Niners of the 80's, and the Cowboys of the 90's. Because the Pro Bowl wasn't established until 1971, and there were so few teams in the 60's, the Packers of the 60's will be excluded from this comparison. Also, my argument will not include Special teams Pro Bowl selections, as I can't find these positions from all the way back in the 70's, or 80's.
The Steelers: The Steelers have won four superbowls, IX (1974), X (1975), XIII (1978), and XIV (1979). In those years, the Steelers respectively had 5, 11, 10, and 10. What team filled with superstars, as they had double digit probowlers in three out of the four seasons in which they won the superbowl.
The Niners: The Niners have won five superbowls, in five tries. These superbowls include: XVI (1981), XIX (1984), XXIII (1988), and XXIV (1989). The niners did win another superbowl in 1995, however this was not the same team, especially considering Young was the QB at the time. In the four superbowls in the dynasty, the Niners had 6, 10, 5, and 6. Unlike the Steelers, the niners had much less probowlers, and we will see that these numbers are similar to the Patriots. This only strengthens the Montana and Brady comparisons, as both teams lacked several superstars, but the bottom line is that the QB's got the job done, and could win big games almost always.
The Cowboys: The Dallas franchise has 5 super bowls, 3 in their dynasty era. The Superbowls came in 1992 (XXVII), 1993 (XXVIII), and 1995 (XXX). In those three super bowl wins, the Cowboys had 6, 11, and 9 probowlers. This is very similar to the Steelers, as after that first super bowl, the number of probowlers increased dramatically. Also, the number of probowlers the Cowboys had was even more amazing considering how many more teams there were in the 90's than the 70's, when the Steelers played.
The Patriots: The Patriot's three super bowls came in the 2001 (XXXVI), 2003 (XXXVIII), and 2004 (XXXIX) super bowl seasons. In these three wins, the Patriots had 2, 3, and 4. This is absolutely ridiculous. How can this team win the Super Bowl 3 times and only have a combined 9 probowlers?!? This is what makes this team so special, the fact that they win as a team and have no superstars. But that makes you wonder how dominant is this team without a large amount of superstars? It makes it even more special, however one more thing is for sure, it is very difficult to compare this team to the Cowboys, Niners, or Steelers, who all had many more probowlers.